Edward Solomon

Bass and contrabass trombone

  • Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • Gallery
  • Lessons
  • Contact
Home » Rachmaninov: Symphony No. 1

Rachmaninov: Symphony No. 1

26 January 2015 by Edward Solomon Leave a Comment

Rachmaninov: Symphony No. 1 in D minor, Op. 13 - Full score
With the onset of winter and an all-Russian programme in the orchestra, what better way to kickstart 2015 than by taking a look at Rachmaninov’s Symphony No. 1 in D minor, Op. 13? We will be performing this work in a few days’ time and have been tirelessly dedicating ourselves to approaching it in the right style.

It seems at first glance a relatively simple work on paper, judging by the range required, but that would be to deny the challenges required, thanks to Rachmaninov’s innovative scoring. In this symphony, Rachmaninov commences a lifetime’s obsession with the Dies irae melody, which most certainly bears fruit in this work, as well as several later masterpieces, including the Symphonic Dances, Op. 45 and the Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini, Op. 43. He also sets about a quite unique way of scoring for the bass trombone, which bears careful consideration.

Unlike Tchaikovsky before him, with which this symphony has close ties, Rachmaninov rarely uses the bass trombone to reinforce the bass line when there is a tuba available. More often that not, the bass trombone is given an inner voice in four-part writing, which presupposes a great deal of musicianship on the part of the performer. Whereas we can, to some extent, put ourselves in a kind of autopilot mode when performing Tchaikovsky, relying on the fact that we double the same line as the cello, bass, bassoon, and tuba, we absolutely cannot do so in the music of Rachmaninov.

With this in mind, let us commence our journey through this dark and troubled symphony, all the while considering that we must have our wits about us constantly, since the rôle we play now requires of us the sensitivity of a chamber musician, listening out for doublings in the wind, horns, and strings, with which we must play nicely.

Movement I: Grave – Allegro ma non troppo

The first movement commences with an arresting triplet figure in the wind, to be repeated throughout the start of each of this symphony’s three remaining movements. The trombones play a unison D, doubled at the octave below by the tuba. Herein lies the very first challenge: not to overstate the case. It is vitally important for the heavy brass to achieve the right balance from the very beginning of the symphony, setting the tone for the rest of the piece, for too loud an interjection at this stage will overplay our hand and there is much yet to enjoy. Therefore it is worth restating that Rachmaninov’s orchestration requires a great deal of care and attention. One should always hear an orchestra, not a heavy brass section accompanied by the rest. It is worth taking a close look at dynamics, as I did when considering Bruckner’s Symphony No. 4, and mentally recalibrating them, by which I mean that one should treat fortississimo as fortissimo, fortissimo as più forte, and the same in reverse for pianississimo and pianissimo. By doing so, we greatly reduce the risk that the heavy brass will overpower the sound picture in loud dynamics (of which there are many in this symphony), or not speak clearly in the frequent quiet passages.

The opening Grave also features the first look at Rachmaninov’s use of articulation. The tenuto line has a special meaning here: it is treated as a semi-hard accent, a step between the standard articulation and the regular accent (>) (in much the same way as the discussion about dynamics above). The regular accent (>) is, however, more pointed than we may think. Russian music of this type requires very heavy, very sharp, and very short accents, with little in the way of sustaining volume, which only gets in the way of more important moving lines elsewhere in the orchestra. Keep this in mind for some important moments later in the symphony.

The Più vivo 11 bars before rehearsal figure 3 is the first of several melodic entrances, in this case doubled by the first trombone an octave higher. It is also an opportunity to see how the whole dynamic/articulation sound picture is made up, with fine gradations of articulation and dynamic already evident as we move from ff pesante to pp in just a few bars. The pp entry after rehearsal figure 3 is a first inversion G minor chord for second trombone, bass trombone, and tuba only. Be sure to make the last two separated notes have a little weight and meaning; don’t throw them away.

After both 7/4 sections, marked by beautiful and plaintive woodwind solos, the bass trombone and tuba enter with the bass line with the rest of the orchestra. Watch carefully during the 7/4, as it’s very easy to be caught out by the irregular meter here. It’s also a point where your rôle changes in a split second from bass line reinforcement to a subsidiary inner voice, so listen very carefully for balance and intonation. 11 bars before rehearsal figure 4 is one of two moments in this movement when you really have to have your wits about you. There is a very short pickup (four demisemiquavers) to the fff quaver A and it is imperative that the entire orchestra plays this together, so count very carefully.

Now the movement really gets underway and builds up toward the first big climax. The strings play a fugato section (featuring some unusual doublings), then the bass trombone and tuba play the bass line on their own. Here is a case in point for the fine use of articulation: the first quaver in each of the two phrases between rehearsal figures 6 and 7 is staccato, then the rest are tenuto (though recall that this means a semi-accent). Place a small, but definite emphasis on the strong beats of the bar, with a slight separation between the notes. These two phrases are not doubled, so the bass trombone and tuba are entirely responsible for carrying the bass line.

From four bars before rehearsal figure 8 begins a build-up to the first big climax, reached at the Maestoso after 8. The pianissimo low E sharp is doubled on the tuba, so balance that one carefully, then build through the rising phrase (with good separation between the notes) until the B minor fortississimo at 8. This is followed by the Maestoso, which requires the exact same stylistic approach from the entire low brass group. All three trombones and tuba must approach the loud, accented chorale with the same length of accent and weight of tone. This is a case in point for the use of short, sharp, heavy accents, backing off slightly in the held notes to allow the high wind (often doubled on the glockenspiel) to come through. It should sound like a Russian male voice choir singing, rather like the same composer’s Vespers. The bass trombone plays an inner voice rôle here, so ease off and allow the high melodic line in the first trombone to carry. At rehearsal figure 10, the full orchestra plays, the bass trombone again playing an inner voice rôle combined with a little judicious bass line reinforcement. As this tutti section is often held back in tempo slightly from rehearsal figure 8, the tempo is very definitely back to Allegro vivace at 12 bars after 10, which is where we encounter the work’s murky past for the first time in the trombone parts.

After the disastrous première, Rachmaninov reputedly destroyed the score and the low brass parts apparently also went missing at the time. The rest of the score was easily reconstructed from the available material, but the low brass parts were a best guess. So what we have is an approximation, since Rachmaninov never sanctioned the performance of this work for the rest of his life. As a result, the passage starting at the Allegro vivace 12 bars before rehearsal figure 10 and ending at L’istesso tempo 14 bars before rehearsal figure 11 is often doctored by conductors. In essence, what we have in the score is a tuba solo, then a bass trombone solo, then a second trombone/tuba soli; however, some conductors put in extra doublings, so that the tuba solo is doubled at the octave by the bass trombone, while the second trombone/tuba soli passage ends up with all three trombones and tuba, the bass trombone on the lower octave line with the tuba. Be prepared for your part to be altered. The written solo line (from the fourth bar of the Allegro vivace 23 bars before rehearsal figure 11) does not need to be particularly loud; it is written in a register that carries easily and should move up seamlessly from the rising tuba line.

The second 7/4 section is scored with the low brass, which enter to fill out the sound picture as an extension of the woodwind/horn crescendo, so don’t overplay the tenuto chords. The Allegro molto 13 bars after figure 13 is just like the previous similar passage, with only four demisemiquavers’ pickup. At rehearsal figure 16, there is a rising pianissimo octave melodic line in the first and second trombones, so be careful to stay well out of the way with the tuba. Your only brief moment is two bars before the Allegro vivace 6/4 (19 bars before the end of the movement), with a short melodic pickup in octaves with the tuba. The movement ends stormily at a very fast pace, so count the bars’ rest carefully, as they fly by quickly.

Movement II: Allegro animato

The scherzo in this symphony is a dark whirlwind of a piece, scurrying and skittering along, marked by a good number of quiet entries and just one loud climax. The bass trombone and tuba enter in unison with the cello/bass line, supporting the overall shape of the descending line with a ppp octave outline. This style of writing occurs frequently in this movement; listen carefully for when the tuba drops out and you continue with the horns. At rehearsal figure 28, the viola section gets its first big moment in the spotlight, while at figure 29 the solo violin with pizzicato string ensemble accompaniment sounds remarkable, presaging Dmitri Shostakovich in years to come. Matters come to a head at the Tempo I after figure 29, where the bass trombone and tuba kick off proceedings with a slow moving fortissimo melodic line, which gradually picks up in speed and pitch. Don’t overstate the case here; you’ll be heard quite easily at a più forte dynamic, which the first trombone can then continue with, when it enters doubling the bass trombone, which drops to the lower octave in the eleventh bar of the Tempo I. Be aware of the fact that the tempo will pick up just before the Tempo I, which moves along at a slightly faster pace.

The climax peters out almost as soon as it begins, with a series of trombone chords quietly underpinning moving melodic lines elsewhere in the orchestra. Be sure to shade off each of these entries (from 12 bars before rehearsal figure 30) with a diminuendo. The rest of the movement features much the same music as appears in the first part of the movement.

Movement III: Larghetto

Instead of the lush, romantic music of the second symphony slow movement, this slow movement is dark, tragic, and melancholy. The trombones have a long wait before the next entry, which is a three-octave, quietly menacing answer to the syncopated horn passage at the Largo un poco 9 bars after rehearsal figure 41. The bass trombone plays the middle octave, sandwiched between the first trombone and the tuba. Listen carefully for balance and intonation and ensure that you remain inside the string sound, not forcing the octaves, but supporting the moving string lines, of which the low brass lines form a small part. The movement features only one more passage for the low brass at rehearsal figure 44, which is a beautifully scored tutti contrasting the rocking motion of three against two, so beloved of Brahms and Bruckner. The bass trombone has an important line, subsidiary to the main melodic line, but nevertheless needing to be enunciated clearly and quite audible. The semi-accent tenuto articulations are a good indicator of the need to emphasise the moving line subtly. The bass trombone starts the line moving, which continues into the first trombone and then the first bassoon, so be sure to set the mood carefully as you would want it to continue, with a slight separation of notes to help in picking out the moving line.

Movement IV: Allegro con fuoco

The last movement is a real tour de force. It starts arrestingly with the same triplet figure each movement has begun with, this time punctuated heavily by the full orchestra. The Marciale is an extremely clever passage, remarkable for its almost imperceptible use of the Dies irae melody (you can hear it if you listen carefully), with the three trumpets well to the fore. Keep the fortissimo down and don’t unleash the full weight of sound until the fortississimo at rehearsal figure 46. The second trombone plays a lower part in this first section, as Rachmaninov clearly preferred to keep the bass trombone anchored to the octave doubling of the bass line with the tuba.

32 bars after rehearsal figure 47 is the first of two similar passages in which the bass trombone and tuba have a snippet of the main melody in octaves, ushering in a tutti. Again, don’t overplay it; keep it subtle. At rehearsal figure 50, we’re back to the same kind of tutti writing as at the beginning of the movement. Watch out for accidentals (there are plenty) and make judicious use of alternate positions. (I find with Rachmaninov that there is frequent use of middle F in 6th position and you may save yourself much energy by doing the same.) The bass trombone and tuba enjoy a small descending melodic phrase here a couple of times.

The next passage to watch out for is the Presto 9 bars before rehearsal figure 59. It really moves quickly, so you’ll need your wits about you. There is a challenging passage from rehearsal figure 60, which rises rapidly to high F sharp, then descends to low G sharp equally quickly in a short section soli. Watch out for the loud tam-tam stroke at this point.

The end of the symphony starts in earnest with the Grave 18 bars before the end. The bass trombone enjoys a melodic line that weaves in and out of unison with the other heavy brass, so listen out carefully for who you are supposed to be paired with. From 14 bars before the end of the symphony, the bass trombone plays an inner voice rôle again, so ease off, stay within the overall low brass sound and don’t be tempted to overblow. The unison string line must be heard clearly from 5 bars before the end, so be sure to deploy short, sharp, heavy accents and back off the dynamics to allow the line through. The grace notes 5 and 3 bars before the end are on the beat, and the low As should sit nicely inside the chord, supporting the rest of the section.

The symphony is quite a journey and the last movement is quite a blow for the low brass, so pace yourself well. Take it easy with the dynamics and you’re already halfway there.

For a taste of what a Russian orchestra can do with this piece, take a look at this recent performance by the Perm Opera and Ballet Theatre, Music Aeterna Orchestra, under conductor Valery Platonov.

  • Facebook
  • Share on X
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
  • Copy Link

Filed Under: orchestra Tagged With: orchestra, Rachmaninov, symphony, trombone

About Edward Solomon

Edward Solomon is a freelance bass and contrabass trombonist in London and works as a Digital Project Manager for PENNInk Productions Ltd.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent posts

Saint-Saëns - Title page from autograph score of Hail! California

Saint-Saëns in the States

You would not place an elderly Camille Saint-Saëns as an innovator, creating a work with a part for contrabass trombone. Yet this is … Read more

Holst and The Cloud Messenger

Unlike most other British composers of the period (with the possible sole exception of Havergal Brian), it turns out that Gustav Holst, who … Read more

Maisie Ringham Wiggins

Maisie Ringham Wiggins (1924-2016)

I realise it has been rather a long time since I last posted, but recent events have taken care of that for me now in a way I did not wish … Read more

Tags

Brahms Bruckner contrabass contrabass trombone German history Holst orchestra Rachmaninov school Schubert symphony Tchaikovsky trombone website

Social

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • instagram
  • linkedin

Copyright © 2026 Edward Solomon

Another PENNInk Production.